Home/Blog/The complete guide to writing employee review templates
Home/Blog/The complete guide to writing employee review templates

The complete guide to writing employee review templates

Areeba Haider
Jan 31, 2024
4 min read
content
What is an employee review?
The importance of an employee review
Types of employee reviews 
Self-reviews
Peer reviews
Quarterly reviews
30/60/90 performance review
Key components of an employee review template
Best practices for a successful employee review 
Final word

What is an employee review?

An employee review template is an evaluation tool for managers. They use it to rate the performance of their team members against a predefined set of criteria. It provides a structured way to discuss a team member’s work, performance, and progress toward their goals. An employee performance review is a great way to figure out what’s working for team members and what changes need to be implemented in order to improve their efficiency and productivity. As a result, it’s important to streamline the evaluation process. For this purpose, an employee review template is an effective choice.

The importance of an employee review

An employee review is of great importance because it aids in the growth and development of employees. Managers are required to review the performance of their team members, which helps them determine how well their team members are meeting their targets and the company’s objectives. It also enables managers to understand how their team members connect with coworkers, which can help address any issues and concerns within the team. Moreover, employee reviews allow managers to identify and reward the top performers. Conversely, those who have performed poorly can be provided with detailed feedback. In this manner, employee reviews help document the employees’ respective growth in their roles over a certain period.

Types of employee reviews 

There’s a variety of employee review templates that we can use. The choice of template will depend on the purpose of the review, the size of the team, and the time period of the performance under evaluation. The major types of employee reviews are as follows: 

  1. Self-reviews

  2. Peer reviews

  3. Quarterly reviews

  4. 30/60/90 performance review

Self-reviews

This is when an employee assesses their own performance. It gives the employees a chance to understand the level of their skills in detail and to identify areas where additional work is required. Employees are able to share their perspectives on their performance, and managers can evaluate the self-review and provide feedback.

Peer reviews

Peer reviews are usually a part of annual performance reviews. These reviews allow team members to evaluate the performance of their peers. Reviews allow employees to see how their coworkers view their performance and offer suggestions for improvement. This is especially helpful with larger teams where not everyone is aware of the other team members’ contributions to projects.

Quarterly reviews

These are the reviews that take place four times a year. The goal is to make sure that team members are meeting the objectives for the quarter and to check in to see if there are any problems or obstacles that need to be sorted. With every quarter, employees are given a chance to improve on their weak points. Similarly, it’s equally essential for managers to mention team member achievements along with areas for improvement.

30/60/90 performance review

Most new employees have a 30/60/90-day plan that lays out the tasks they are expected to complete within the defined time frame. These plans aim at preparing new hires for their positions so that they can fully contribute to the team, just like the other employees. This performance review aims to provide feedback to the new hires and also point out areas of improvement.

Key components of an employee review template

A well-structured employee review template contains certain elements that ensure that the SMART goals set for the review are fulfilled. The key components of an employee review template are as follows:

Employee strengths: These are the core competencies at which the employee excels. Employees should maintain their performance in these areas.

Employee weaknesses: These are the skills in which the employee falls short, requiring further improvement.

Performance criteria: This is the rating system, or the metrics used to measure the performance of the employees. These can be KPIs or OKRs.

Review period: This is the set time frame within which the employee is expected to meet the set goals.

Future goals and objectives: These are the deliverables that determine how productive an employee has been. Managers generally use SMART goals to guide team members in their tasks.

Best practices for a successful employee review 

An effective employee review is essential for the growth of employees. An employee review must be crafted in a precise manner so that the employee performance evaluation is accurate. To help with this process, we’ve curated a list of best practices for a successful employee review:

  • Set SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timely) goals.

  • Provide clarity regarding the purpose of the employee review.

  • Select the right metric for evaluating performance.

  • Foster a positive environment for review by remaining constructive and motivating.

  • Remain objective in order to ensure a fair assessment.

  • Avoid using technical language loaded with jargon. Instead, use plain language to avoid ambiguities.

  • Offer detailed feedback supported by data insights.

Final word

An employee review template is an important tool that helps managers measure the success of their employees. A good employee review covers every employee’s achievements, failures, and feedback so that they know how to further improve themselves in their positions. Employee reviews also define the future path for teams by outlining new goals and objectives.


  

Free Resources

DevPath by Educative. Copyright ©2025 Educative, Inc. All rights reserved.

soc2