As engineering managers, you know the struggle of balancing innovation with technical debt in software development. You want to deliver cutting-edge software that meets the needs of our users, but you also want to avoid the long-term consequences of tech debt. One of the biggest challenges is finding the right balance between the two. You might find yourself in a scenario similar to one of the two below:
Scenario #1:
Perhaps you’ve once worked with team members that was so focused on innovation that they neglected tech debt. They were constantly pushing out new features, and the software seemed to be progressing rapidly. However, after a few months, you noticed significant performance issues and vulnerabilities. It turned out that tech debt had accumulated over time, making it difficult to add new features or fix existing ones. The team had to step back and focus on reducing the technical debt before continuing their innovation.
Scenario #2:
You’ve joined a new team and have initial pressure from leadership and your managers to build innovative solutions to drive the business forward. However, you’ve also inherited a product that has significant performance and stability issues from unresolved technical debt and shortcuts during its build. You’re stuck with the backlog of reducing technical debt, while driving innovation for your product.
Strategies for balancing technical debt and innovation:
In this article, we'll explore some strategies for balancing managing technical debt and innovation. We'll discuss the following:
1. Understanding risks
2. Communicating the importance of prioritizing technical debt
3. Using innovation to address technical debt
4. Keeping your eye on the big picture.
By the end of this article, you'll have a better understanding of how to balance innovation and technical debt and explore some strategies to achieve that balance.
Understand the risks
When it comes to understanding the risks of innovation and technical debt, it's important to consider both short-term and long-term consequences. Innovation can be risky in the short term because it involves trying new technologies and taking risks that may not always pay off. On the other hand, technical debt can be risky in the long term because it can accumulate over time and make it harder to maintain, scale, or update the software.
For example, let's say a team decides to innovate by implementing a new feature that involves a complex algorithm. While the feature may work well initially, the team may not have considered the long-term consequences of using this algorithm. Over time, the algorithm may become inefficient, causing the software to slow down or become unstable. The team may then have an inadvertent consequence of spending a significant amount of time and resources to refactor the code, which could have been avoided by considering all the tradeoffs.
Communicate the value of prioritizing technical debt
To achieve a balance between innovation and technical debt, it's crucial to communicate the value of prioritizing technical debt. Refactoring, cleaning up code, and improving performance may not produce tangible results, but it's essential for the software's long-term viability. While business stakeholders may have trouble understanding the value of prioritizing technical debt, there are ways to frame the work by focusing on its impact in reducing the drag on productivity and making it easier to innovate in the long run.
While this process may take some time and may not produce immediate results, it will make it easier for the team to implement upgrades and new features, fix bugs, and maintain the software in the long run. As a result, the team will be able to work more efficiently and effectively, ultimately leading to faster innovation and better software.
In summary:
Prioritizing technical debt is crucial for achieving a balance between innovation and technical debt in software engineering.
Refactoring, cleaning up code, and improving performance may not always produce immediate results, but they're essential for the software's long-term viability.
By prioritizing technical debt, teams can reduce the drag on productivity and make it easier to innovate in the long run.
Use innovation to address technical debt
Innovation can be an effective tool for addressing technical debt. Rather than simply addressing technical debt through incremental changes to existing code, innovation can offer creative and comprehensive solutions that can help eliminate technical debt and create more maintainable and scalable software.
Your team can start by creating more efficient processes and workflows that can help reduce technical debt. For example, a team may use automation tools to streamline their testing process, reducing the likelihood of introducing bugs and technical debt. By continuously innovating and improving their development processes, teams can reduce the amount of technical debt they accumulate over time.
For example, let's say a team is dealing with a legacy system that has become difficult to maintain due to technical debt. The codebase has grown in complexity over time, making it hard to add new features and fix bugs. The team decides to use innovation to create a new codebase from scratch.
Creating a new codebase from scratch is a significant undertaking, but it can help eliminate technical debt and create a more maintainable and scalable solution. By building a new codebase from the ground up, the team can ensure that the new codebase is designed with modern software development principles in mind, making it easier to maintain and scale over time.
Moreover, creating a new codebase can help reduce the drag on productivity caused by technical debt. The team can start with a clean slate and build a codebase that's optimized for their specific needs, rather than trying to navigate around the issues caused by technical debt from legacy code or bad code.
In summary:
By continuously innovating and improving processes, teams can reduce the amount of technical debt they accumulate over time.
Creating a new codebase from scratch is one example of using innovation to eliminate technical debt and create more maintainable and scalable software.
Using automation tools to streamline processes is another way that innovation can help reduce technical debt.
Keep your eye on the big picture
Keeping your eye on the big picture is crucial for achieving the right balance between innovation and technical debt in software development. To achieve this balance, it's important to understand how innovation and technical debt fit into the overall business strategy to meet business goals and needs.
One real-life example of balancing innovation and technical debt in the context of the overall business strategy is Amazon's approach to software development. Amazon's business strategy is based on a relentless focus on customer needs, innovation, and operational efficiency. To achieve these goals, Amazon's development teams are encouraged to experiment, take risks, and innovate, but also to prioritize technical debt reduction and maintainability.
One way Amazon achieves this balance is through the use of two-pizza teams — small, independent teams that could be fed by two pizzas — that are responsible for a specific area of the software. These teams are empowered to make decisions about their codebase and are held accountable for the code quality and maintainability. By giving teams ownership and autonomy, Amazon fosters a culture of innovation and technical excellence.
However, Amazon's development teams are also expected to prioritize customer needs and to deliver software quickly and efficiently. This means that while technical debt reduction and maintainability are essential, they must be balanced against innovation and time-to-market considerations.
To ensure that their teams understand the company's goals and priorities, Amazon also emphasizes communication and collaboration between teams. Teams are encouraged to share knowledge and best practices and to work together to achieve the company's goals.
In summary:
Empower teams for innovation and technical excellence.
Prioritize technical debt reduction and maintainability.
Foster communication and collaboration between teams.
Delivers quality software that meets customer needs.
How can DevPath help?
Our workspace offers a shared space for your internal knowledge where you can easily:
Capture and reference all your docs, code, and engineering enablement resources by embedding Confluence docs, Google docs, pdfs, and more for any software project.
Assign seamless onboarding plans with access to 600+ technical courses, including topics such as DevOps, AI, Machine Learning, and System Design.
Track internal doc reading progress and documentation process from one dashboard. You’ll be able to communicate business needs and maintain high-quality documentation through a verifiable workflow.
Your team will measurably decrease training delays, code review time, and documentation errors to avoid rework or code debt in the future.
For a limited time, click below to receive free access to our platform.
Free Resources
