What is the Hawthorne effect?
The term Hawthorne effect was coined by Henry A. Landsberger in 1958 to describe the phenomenon where people alter their behavior due to the awareness that they are being observed. The term traces back to experiments Elton Mayo and his team conducted at the Western Electric Hawthorne Works in Chicago from 1924–1932. The Hawthorne experiments were groundbreaking as they contextualized workplace productivity within a social framework, illustrating that workers are significantly influenced by their environment more than their capabilities alone. These studies underscore the importance of considering how observation can affect teams’ performance. Regardless of environmental adjustments such as lighting, workers’ productivity increased whenever they perceived being observed. Hence, the Hawthorne effect is particularly relevant for tech teams, where the awareness of observation can influence productivity and work dynamics, irrespective of other changes in the work environment.
Hawthorne effect and tech leadership
The Hawthorne effect can significantly shape the dynamics within tech teams. When leaders actively monitor their teams, employees often adjust their behaviors to align with the expectations they perceive are being measured. This heightened sense of observation can lead to improvements such as increased diligence and compliance with project standards. However, tech leaders need to be aware of the deeper implications of this behavioral change. Continuous monitoring might inadvertently suppress genuine expressions of concern or creativity among team members, as they might prioritize conforming over innovating. This can stifle the development of new ideas, which are crucial for technological advancement and competitive advantage. Furthermore, the constant pressure to perform under watchful eyes can lead to stress and burnout, detrimental to individual well-being and team cohesion. Hence, effective tech leaders should foster a supportive atmosphere that values open communication and encourages risk-taking without fear of negative repercussions.
Impact of the Hawthorne effect on tech teams
For tech professionals, constant observation can lead to positive changes, such as increased productivity, and negative consequences, such as reduced innovation and increased stress. This is why engineering leadership needs to understand the impact of the Hawthorne effect on tech teams to foster a healthy and productive work environment while maintaining the delicate balance between supervision and employee autonomy. The Hawthorne effect impacts tech teams in the following five ways:
Behavioral adjustment
Quality of work
Innovation suppression
Employee morale and stress
Cultural shift
Behavioral adjustment
Tech professionals may alter their work habits and behaviors in response to being observed. This can result in temporary productivity boosts as individuals strive to meet or exceed the expectations that they believe managers are monitoring. For example, in a dev team, introducing activity-tracking tools might lead team members to spend more time coding or documenting their process to demonstrate productivity, potentially at the expense of collaborative brainstorming sessions.
Quality of work
While the quantity of work may increase, the quality can suffer if tech team members rush tasks or prioritize speed over thoroughness due to the perception of constant observation. This might lead to issues like software bugs or inadequate problem-solving, which require additional revision cycles. For example, under constant surveillance, a QA (quality assurance) team might prioritize clearing as many tickets as possible within a sprint. This can lead to superficial checks that miss deeper, systemic bugs, affecting the software’s reliability and leading to more significant issues.
Innovation suppression
The fear of failing under observation might deter tech professionals from taking necessary risks, essential for breakthroughs and creative solutions in the tech sector. For example, a tech team working on an AI project may use established algorithms and methods rather than experimenting with new techniques. The fear of failure under observation can stifle creative problem-solving and slow the adoption of potentially revolutionary software technologies.
Employee morale and stress
In a tech company, a developer may feel pressured to always appear busy, leading to longer hours and stress-related health issues. This environment can create a high-stress culture, reducing job satisfaction and leading valuable employees to seek less oppressive work environments. The feeling of being constantly watched can also diminish the sense of autonomy and trust, which are crucial components of motivation and team engagement.
Cultural shift
Over time, the Hawthorne effect can influence the organizational culture, leading to a work environment emphasizing surveillance and productivity metrics over collaboration and personal growth. This shift can impact how teams communicate and how leaders are perceived, potentially creating a more hierarchical and less approachable managerial style.
Final word
The Hawthorne effect highlights how individuals change their behavior simply because they know they’re being monitored. This effect is particularly intriguing for tech teams as it highlights how awareness of observation can significantly influence team dynamics and productivity.
Free Resources
