Inference: Addition, Conjunction, and Simplification

Learn about more rules of inference for the construction and understanding of mathematical arguments.

Addition

If we know that q1q_1 is true, we can consistently conclude that, (q1q2)\left(q_1\lor q_2\right) is true. Here q2q_2 is an arbitrary proposition. This rule of inference is called addition. The following statement is always true.

“If q1q_1 is true then q1q2q_1 \lor q_2 is also true.”

We can write this tautology as follows:

q1(q1q2).q_1 \Rightarrow \left(q_1\lor q_2\right).

Examples

Let’s look at a few examples to see this rule in action.


Let’s take two propositions.

  • RAR_A: Robert is eating an apple.
  • ROR_O: Robert is eating an orange.

Consider that RAR_A is true, and we do not know about ROR_O whether it is true or not. We can conclude that the following proposition is true by the addition rule.

RAROR_A \lor R_O: Robert is eating an apple or an orange.

Because RAR_A is true, RAROR_A \lor R_O is true, and ROR_O can be true or false.

Robert

For the next example, consider the following two propositions.

  • LL: 2<2.\sqrt{2} < 2.
  • EE: 2=2.\sqrt{2} = 2.

As LL is true, we know that the following proposition is true by the addition rule.

LE:22.L \lor E : \sqrt{2} \le 2.

Conjunction

If we know that q1q_1 is true and we also know independently that q2q_2 is true, we can conclude that (q1q2)\left(q_1\land q_2\right) is true.

Examples

Let’s look at some examples.


Assume that the following two propositions are true:

  • CTC_T: A car has four tires.
  • CWC_{W}: A car has a steering wheel.

We can conclude that the following proposition is true by applying the rule of conjunction.

  • CTCWC_T \land C_{W}: A car has four tires and a steering wheel.

Let’s look at the next example.


Consider the following two propositions are true:

  • RFR_{F}: The rose bush has red flowers.
  • GLG_{L}: The rose bush has green leaves.

We can conclude that the following proposition is also true by the rule of conjunction.

  • RFGLR_{F}\land G_{L}: The rose bush has red flowers and green leaves.
Rose bush

Simplification

If we know that (q1q2)\left(q_1\land q_2\right) is true, we can conclude that q1q_1 is true. We can write it as the following tautology:

(q1q2)q1.\left(q_1 \land q_2\right)\Rightarrow q_1.

Examples

For further elaboration, let’s look at a few examples.


Consider the following two propositions:

  • NGHN_{GH}: Nutritious food is good for health.
  • EGHE_{GH}: Exercise is good for health.

We assume that the following proposition is true.

  • NGHEGHN_{GH}\land E_{GH}: Nutritious food and exercise are good for health.
Nutritious food and exercise
Nutritious food and exercise

From the fact above, we can conclude that the following proposition is true.

  • NGHN_{GH}: Nutritious food is good for health.

Indeed, we can also conclude that EGHE_{GH} is true.


For the next example, take the following propositions.

  • OVCO_{VC}: Oranges are rich in vitamin C.
  • ORFO_{RF}: Oranges are rich in fiber.

Assume that OVCORFO_{VC}\land O_{RF} is true.

  • OVCORFO_{VC}\land O_{RF}: Oranges are rich in fiber and vitamin C.

Then we can conclude that OVCO_{VC} is true.

Oranges

Quiz

Test your understanding of rules of inference.

1

Consider two propositions q1q_1 and q2q_2. Then, according to the simplification rule, we can conclude that q1q_1 is true if:

A)

q1q2q_1 \lor q_2 is true.

B)

q1q2q_1 \Rightarrow q_2 is true.

C)

q1q2q_1 \land q_2 is true.

D)

q1q2q_1 \Leftrightarrow q_2.

Question 1 of 30 attempted